MOVIEPIQ · MYSTERY · CURATED LIST

Best Mystery Movies On A First Date Night In From The 2000S That Will Make You Cry

The best mystery movies on a first date night in from the 2000s that will make you cry. Includes The Constant Gardener, Broken Flowers, The Crimson Rivers an...

A good first date film gives you something to talk about without making you explain yourself. It should open a conversation, not close one down.

The 2000s feel undervalued now. A decade of films that knew what they were doing and did it without apology.

A great mystery is built on trust. The film shows you every clue — and still manages to surprise you.

The Constant Gardener movie poster
1
2005 · ★★★½☆ 7.0/10

Justin Quayle is a low-level British diplomat who has always gone about his work very quietly, not causing any problems. But after his radical wife Tessa is killed he becomes determined to find out why, thrusting himself into the middle of a very dangerous conspiracy.

Broken Flowers movie poster
2
2005 · ★★★½☆ 6.9/10

An introverted man receives an anonymous letter from an ex-lover informing him that he has a son who may be looking for him. A freelance sleuth neighbor motivates the man to embark on a cross-country search for his past flames, seeking answers.

The Crimson Rivers movie poster
3
2000 · ★★★½☆ 6.9/10

Two French policemen, one investigating a grisly murder at a remote mountain college, the other working on the desecration of a young girl's grave by skinheads, are brought together by the clues from their respective cases. Soon after they start working together, more murders are committed, and the pair begin to discover just what dark secrets are behind the killings.

8 Women movie poster
4
2002 · ★★★½☆ 6.9/10

Eight women gather to celebrate Christmas in a snowbound cottage, only to find the family patriarch dead with a knife in his back. Trapped in the house, every woman becomes a suspect, each having her own motive and secret.

The Jacket movie poster
5
2005 · ★★★½☆ 6.9/10

A military veteran goes on a journey into the future, where he can foresee his death and is left with questions that could save his life and those he loves.

A great mystery never cheats. These films play fair — which makes it all the more impressive when they still manage to surprise you.

Brick movie poster
6
2006 · ★★★½☆ 6.8/10

A teenage loner pushes his way into the underworld of a high school crime ring to investigate the disappearance of his ex-girlfriend.

Vanilla Sky movie poster
7
2001 · ★★★½☆ 6.8/10

David Aames has it all: wealth, good looks and gorgeous women on his arm. But just as he begins falling for the warmhearted Sofia, his face is horribly disfigured in a car accident. That's just the beginning of his troubles as the lines between illusion and reality, between life and death, are blurred.

Gosford Park movie poster
8
2001 · ★★★½☆ 6.8/10

In 1930s England, a group of pretentious rich and famous gather together for a weekend of relaxation at a hunting resort. But when a murder occurs, each one of these interesting characters becomes a suspect.

Dark Water movie poster
9
2002 · ★★★½☆ 6.8/10

A woman in the midst of an unpleasant divorce moves to an eerie apartment building with her young daughter. The ceiling of their apartment has a dark and active leak.

Wicker Park movie poster
10
2004 · ★★★½☆ 6.8/10

Matthew, a young advertising executive in Chicago, puts his life and a business trip to China on hold when he thinks he sees Lisa, the love of his life who left him without a word two years earlier, walking out of a restaurant one day.

Great films that make you cry do so because they've made you care. By the time the emotion lands, you're not surprised — you're just not ready for it.

Great mystery cinema changes how you watch everything else. You start looking for the clues in every story.